Skip to content

Harry Potter-Book 7

  1. Forums
  2. Book club
  3. Harry Potter-Book 7

First post in thread.

12/6/07 18:37

Login to reply

cate1976

Yet again we have to start a new thread.  I hope this is the last time.  The original from the old forums is in Debates but thought  it best to carry on from whwere we left off.  At least the May threads are still accessible but I intend to save just in case.

  1. 11/10/07 14:39

    Login to reply

    Na1play

    I cried watching the last two. Now I have a lump in my throat that won't go away.

  2. 11/10/07 14:06

    Login to reply

    Orlando!

    Oh and speaking of Munters.... get your butt over there ILF&G have tried to start a new debate but as usual I just the one sentence reply!!!!

    Just managed to make myself into an emotional wreckage by watching YouTube vids.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lMOYntt4Hj8&mode=related&search=

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=exeRKZ6mg9Y&NR=1

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q69ZJkC-JZw&mode=related&search=

     

    WHY do I do it to myself??? *runs away, tears streaming down her face*

  3. 11/10/07 13:06

    Login to reply

    Cheeky!Orlando!

    You have sussed me out Jo - when I text you the other night I was not really on my laptop browsing Munters and chatting on MSN with a glass of vino in one hand. I was in fact at a fancy book signing gig in New York whilst chatting via the internet with my assistant at Bloomsbury  with regards to the Encyclopedia.

     

     

    *Disclaimer*

    Just incase anybody desperately stupid - or fab with Law reads this - I am NOT, I repeat NOT JK and I am not pretending to be so. But I do have daughers called Jessica and Mackenzie

  4. 10/10/07 20:11

    Login to reply

    Cheeky!SallieAnne

    Hhhmmmm, does sound a bit suspicous(sp)!!

  5. 10/10/07 20:05

    Login to reply

    I loveFred (and george!)

    Ho Hum,Daughters by the same name ayy??!!Sure you is not the really real one Orlando,or who ever you may be!!!!

  6. 10/10/07 10:21

    Login to reply

    Michelleplus3

    As soon as id written it i knew id make spelling mistakes! in the excitement of it all! lol.

    Fab info hun! thank you x

  7. 9/10/07 14:28

    Login to reply

    Orlando!

    You mean the Fidelius Charm on Grimmauld Place??

    *puffs out chest*

    http://www.beyondhogwarts.com/harry-potter/articles/the-secrets-of-the-fidelius-charm.html

    Read that, it is MY article written on the subject.

    I post on there as Orlando too, but the article is in my 'Sunday' name

  8. 9/10/07 10:00

    Login to reply

    Michelleplus3

    OMG! Hedwig and Moody in the first 100 pages!

    Im a little confuddled about the charm on Grindwald though? If someone could just Apparate in their by holding onto someones sleeve?

  9. 8/10/07 11:54

    Login to reply

    Cheeky!Orlando!

    She would have to be allowed - because her daughters are called Jessica and Mackenzie - and I have daughters called that too

  10. 8/10/07 04:34

    Login to reply

    I loveFred (and george!)

    Aaw thanks Sallie!!Tis nice to be missed

    Also yes Orlando JKR would have to ask,but she may not be allowed!!!

    However I think you should be JK for a while and answer the questions,I think you have researched the books alot more than the real author has!!

  11. 6/10/07 20:15

    Login to reply

    Orlando!

    If I were JKR I would sit on the internet scouring the different HP sites such as MuggleNet, CoS, BeyondHogwarts etc (and of course this thread - although for the indepth view she would have to ASK to join) AND then create smarty pant answers to each and every flaw and put it in her encyclopedia.

    I would explain properly just HOW the Elder Wand was deemed to have been justly won by Grindelwald -  but not by Voldemort (who stole it just the same...)

    I would explain just WHY Fred & George failed to notice that everywhere their brother went (when looking at the Marauder's Map) he was accompanied by Peter Pettigrew.

    I would explain how the prophecy and the idea of freedom of choice sit together - cause they just DON'T

    I would explain the Fidelius Charm - in depth and prove that it is safe - and not just the lucky dip it appears to be.

    I could go on...... ( I usually do )

  12. 6/10/07 15:32

    Login to reply

    Smiling at youSallieAnne

    Ive missed you I F (&G)!!

  13. 5/10/07 22:47

    Login to reply

    I loveFred (and george!)

    *dashes in dramatically with BIG news*

    In case anyone doesnt know HP is flawed,flawed I tell you,bad JKR!!!!

    How many more things will we find that she didnt notice,I wonder,perhaps she should have sacked her publisher,coz they obviously didnt pick up on the FLAWS either..........Grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr JK!!!

    Makes for good debating though,have already since DH came out debated and nit picked flaws with Orlando about:

    The Marauders Map,The Fidelius Charm,The Invisibility Cloak,The Elder Wand,The Resurrection Stone,Dumbledore........and more that I cant think of!!!!

    But tis all good fun isnt it!!!!!!!!!!

    Will try to get back on bit more often,but nothing seemed to happen on here for ages and then all of a sudden,wham,everyone sneaks on when I disappear for a bit!!!!!!

  14. 4/10/07 19:28

    Login to reply

    Smiling at youSallieAnne

    Well i always said i wouldnt buy them til all were out in one megaboxset, but ive given in and only PS is here so ds is driving me mad watching it over and over but hes upset that he hasnt seen Dobby or heard EXPECTO PATRONUM yet!

    The link i watched it on stopped working. i hope yours works!

  15. 4/10/07 19:07

    Login to reply

    Orlando!

    I have a link to watch OotP too - I might do, sit in bed with my laptop and plug in the old earphones for total surround sound.... after all I have seen it at the cinema 4 times - and I have it on Pre-order from Play.

    Want to see HBP right now AND DH 

  16. 1/10/07 18:50

    Login to reply

    Smiling at youSallieAnne

    Yeah could be!! lmao!! He just sounds like a right twonk!!

    I found it on a website and i clicked the link to see if it worked, it did ended up watching the whole film *naughty me i know!* xand went nuts naming characters!! Was dissapointed when he said is that dobby look and it was kreacher!! Cant wait to get the dvd now though for thesneak peak!! and if you care, probly dont as youve more than likely got them all but... on CDWOW they have cos,poa & gof s disk special editions for 4.99 each! i got them and narnia,lol.

  17. 1/10/07 17:25

    Login to reply

    Orlando!

    PMSL Sallie - yes, Dudley has certainly altered his speech. Perhaps it is due to all the punches he must receive being the regional amateur boxing champ

    Where's your mother?? She dead??

    Don't kill Cedric ... who's he? Your boyfriend???

  18. 1/10/07 10:27

    Login to reply

    I have a questionSallieAnne

    what i wanna know is why does dudley talk like he has a mouthful full cotton balls at the start of OOTP?!?!?!

  19. 30/9/07 10:29

    Login to reply

    Orlando!

    Michelle, I see what you mean. I think we are meant to assume that after he crumpled the parchment in his hand he put it back in the locket - I mean you wouldn't really throw something like that away.

    When Harry shows Ron the locket he opens it first and obviously Ron reads the message, hence the 'who is R.A.B' question.

    After years of reading HP I can say - JK makes assumptions, in that - things that are obvious to her should automatically be obvious to everyone else. It was like when she got asked how on earth Fred and George worked out how to use the Marauders Map - she was flummoxed, thought it was 'obvious' and nobody would ask a question like that.

    When she wrote that Harry crumpled the note in his hand it does seem to imply he would have thrown it away, but clearly he didn't - he screwed it up, put it back in the locket where it became perfectly legible within the casing of the locket to enable Ron to read it

  20. 29/9/07 17:11

    Login to reply

    SallieAnne

    orlando worked it out and was right!! shes a freeaking genius!!! GENIUS!!!

Bookmark and Share
Forum Selector
Advertisment

Quick navigation

Please select a forum topic from the list below:

Information and rules

Planning your pregnancy

Baby on board

Dad Zone

New arrivals to toddler years

Growing families

Me Time

Support

Book club calendar

January 2009

  1. < Previous Month
S M T W Th F S
        123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Use the calander tool to navigate the forums by thread creation date

Latest news

Loading...

Weekly poll

Loading...

in association with Huggies

Bounty.com

Go to My Bounty

Oops! You don't appear to be logged in!

The information on Bounty.com is not a substitute for examination, diagnosis or treatment by a qualified health professional.

Copyright © 2001-2008 Bounty (UK) Ltd. All rights reserved.